Ray was taller than I
expected from the photos on his book covers, and thinner. He looked me over,
too, but I couldn’t tell what he was thinking. I made small talk while we
waited for my luggage, but he was silent.
When we were finally in
his truck heading to Whitefish, he cleared his throat. “Well, you’ve had quite
a day, Mary. Twelve hours, three planes. You must be tired.”
I’d rehearsed my response:
“I would have taken a wagon train if that was the only way to get here.” I
watched his face as he repeated what I’d said with only a slight intake of
breath, no further comment.
We talked about flying.
I’d read that Ray wouldn’t fly, drove his truck wherever he went to teach or
give a reading.
He quickly assured me he was not afraid to fly.
“Well, I’m afraid, Ray,
but I do it. Anyway, dying in a plane crash might be the best way to go. You’d
have time for final thoughts the whole way down. The right kind. Not like when
I was sideswiped in my car at rush hour, went into a tailspin, only had time to
think, ‘Oh shit!’”
He kept his eyes on the
road. I shifted toward him on the seat with my left knee up, alert to his profile.
His brows were thatched; his cheekbones might as well have been carved of ice.
“Even if you panicked at
the loss of altitude,” I continued, “you’d think the pilot might regain
control. And you wouldn’t be alone, not like being murdered in a back alley.”
I could barely swallow, I
was so nervous to finally meet him, but I couldn’t seem to stop talking.
“You could hold hands with
the person next to you, reassure each other, keep praying the pilot would pull
out of the nose-dive. But if it crashed, the end would be so quick you wouldn’t
have time to lose hope completely.”
Ray listened, impassive.
Finally I asked, “If you’re not afraid, why don’t you fly?”
“It’s a long way down.”
Clearly, this was not a
topic he wanted to pursue. And I didn’t know enough about him yet to presume
when, or if, I could push. We had a kind of history but were strangers, really.
His friend Stephen had come across one of Ray’s poems at my web site and
introduced himself by e-mail, informing me that Ray was pleased to know I’d
featured him, but didn’t own a computer. “Since he has no hardware, he
suggested you call him at his mountain retreat in Montana.”
* * *
I’d had no desire to
contact Ray. I did, though, read everything he’d written – poems, short
stories, memoirs, a novel. He was a good story-teller, the first and only poet
whose collections I read from cover to cover, admiring every single poem. In most
interviews, he’d emphasized that he was a purist who wrote everything first in
longhand with a #2 pencil, painstakingly typing his revisions on an
old-fashioned typewriter.
Then Ray had phoned,
pitching a slow curve. At first he showed interest in me, asked what role
poetry played in my work as a personal coach, then abruptly said I seemed to be
using his poem for personal gain, and should contact his agent for written
permission. I reverted to a maddening nervous habit – choking, speaking
hoarsely – feeling foolish.
The second time, he called
because he didn’t recognize my number on his phone bill. When I picked up the
receiver, he barked, “Who is this?”
“I believe you called me.”
“Oh, you’re the lady who
quoted me without permission.”
“No. As a matter of fact I
took your poem off my web site.”
“I didn’t want you to take
it off! I just thought you should get permission.”
“Fine, Ray. When I have
time, I’ll get around to it.”
A month later, hoping to
allay any future calls, I’d typed a letter to him explaining I’d done as he’d
asked, reinstating his poem at my web site, with written permission. Stephen
had been working on me, telling me Ray, though somewhat gruff, was a good
person and I should not be too hard on him. So I tried to be gracious, but not
too gracious – a little smart-alecky, or funny, maybe.
“Dear Ray, I’m writing
instead of calling to try to get on a better footing with you, having found
myself with my foot in my mouth (maybe your foot in my mouth) in our two brief
conversations.”
I closed with what I
thought would end our correspondence, “I hope your life continues to be as
rich, amusing, and sentimentally deep as it appears to have been so far.”
* * *
I forgot about Ray over
the next few weeks and was surprised when he replied (in #2 pencil), “Dear
Mary, it seems we are in a story, you and I, connected, as we are, in our own
imaginations. My, my.”
I had to sit down.
“But the story is tilted,”
Ray’s letter continued, “since you know much more about me than I know about
you. What can you tell me about yourself?”
Writing to him was easier
than talking on the phone.
Cued by Stephen, I’d
re-read Ray’s poems with a different eye. I could love a man who writes as
he does.
“I have Mingus on my
mind,” I responded to his “My, my” letter. “I heard a piece on the radio in Boston in the sixties that
left me flat out in love. Only I thought it was Alice in Wonderland, and couldn’t
track it down. Last week, after searching all these years, I found it – Alice’s Wonderland! It’s less than nine
minutes long, but worth the wait.”
Again, there was a
three-week interval, then another letter from Ray. “Good touch, the Mingus,
because of the title of the tune and the nine minutes. I, too, am a Mingus fan
– do you know his autobiography? Wonderful description of Ellington firing
him.”
His writing was
surprisingly formal, almost stilted. I wonder if he’s cautious about letters
that might be published without his consent? He enclosed a newspaper
clipping about one of his readings, which I found both egotistical and
touching.
When we began talking
regularly by phone, it took a while to find our way. I couldn’t help responding
to his flirtatiousness, and discovered he liked me to be a little cheeky.
“I think writing in pencil
works for you,” I said one night, “because you dip it in testosterone.”
“You’re not the first
woman to tell me that.”
But I had difficulty
reconciling the poetic writer with the exacting man. Remembering my comment
about his sentimentally deep life,
Ray drummed out a lecture on the difference between sentiment and sentimentality.
“Rod McCuen, that’s sentimentality!”
I wondered what he found
of interest in me. Is it because I’m crazy about his writing?
* * *
Ray continued to be
abrupt, though in a rough, sexy way. Frankness and earthy humor became our
theme, sometimes with a literary slant. He asked me one night, “What’s the most
screwed-up thing about you?”
“My fondness for shoes. I
have forty pairs.”
“Forty pairs!” He was
astonished, but didn’t miss a beat. “Are any of them red?”
I followed this exchange
by sending him a short remake of Hans Christian Andersen’s The Red Shoes,
starring myself and changing the traditional ending.
“Now what might you take
to be the moral of this tale? All we know is that our girl is grown up now and
she’s willing to take her chances if there’s a prince of a guy who likes to
dance.”
Ray was amused. Later I’d
note the irony that we were better for each other on paper. At that time I was
beginning to feel an attraction, though not without misgivings.
“There’s a danger for me,”
I wrote to him, “in believing a story that may not be true.” That hadn’t
stopped me, however, from playing out the story. “I’ve been reading Mary Karr’s
The Liar’s Club. Her Daddy described a woman with an ass ‘like two
bulldog pups in a sack.’ Now, don’t expect that from my ass, Ray.”
One night on the phone,
searching for a common thread, we discovered we’d both been single for many
years after an early marriage, and began to joke about our parallel strings of
lovers.
“Am I your one and only
writer?” he’d asked.
“Dear One and Only,” I wrote. “I think the
approximate count is fifteen, and in review I’m disheartened to note how sadly
underrepresented the arts have been in my life. Yes, Ray, almost everyone
‘writes,’ but you are my only writer. Not surprisingly, there was more than one
psychiatrist, but good God, there were two lawyers and a judge! Strangest of
all, there was a pineapple canning plant manager.”
Ray called that night to
report he’d had sex with a woman in every state of the union except Hawaii.
“Well, there you go,” I
said. “I’ve taken care of Hawaii.”
That went on for a while,
the two of us trying to find out who, really, was on the other end of the line.
He asked me to track down a recording by Norah Jones, “Come Away With Me.” When
I listened to it I suspected another woman had told him about it. Still, I was
touched by the lyrics of Lonestar:
How far you are I just
don’t know / the distance I’m willing to go. I pick up a stone that I cast to
the sky / hoping for some kind of sign.
I was torn between
intrigue and doubt. Ray could be preachy. In response to my questions about his
only novel, he’d written “You’re being a psychologist who wants to figure
things out. To the writer these can never be interesting questions.” Then he’d
relented: “But when you say reading it hurt like hell, I’m rewarded. Part of my
purpose is to make the reader feel – or
as Conrad says, ‘see.’’’
After four months of
letters and phone calls, I still wasn’t sure how I felt about Ray. I wanted to
either end the flirtation or find out if there could be more to the
relationship.
I need to spend some time with him in person.
This was resolved when he
told me about the July 4th celebration in Whitefish. “You would have enjoyed
it, Mary. You should have been here.”
“Are you asking me to
visit, Ray?”
“If I asked you, would you
come?”
* * *
Now I was on Ray’s
mountain. It was so beautiful, so calm there, I felt almost delirious, hugging
him at every opportunity. In our last conversation before my flight, in fact,
I’d asked him to embrace me as soon as I deplaned on Friday. “Act as if we know
each other.”
“Of course.” The same
response he’d given when I said I’d like to sleep next to him, not in the guest
bedroom.
“I’m like a mole,” I said.
“I have to sniff and feel my way along.”
“Are you blind?”
“No! But if we don’t get
it over with right away, I’ll be edgy.”
Friday night was awkward.
* * *
Early on Saturday, I
breathed in the sweet, piney scent from the open window, heard the walls wake
up with creaks and snaps, like a cedar body stretching. A breathing house.
Next to me, Ray’s lean body felt polite; it did not yield. He let me hold him the
way a small boy might who’s been instructed to accept a stranger’s embrace, who
complies because he should.
Later in the day, when it
was cooler, we drove to the river to fish. I told him I’d been fly-fishing in Wyoming two years
before, but asked him to remind me what to do. He showed me how to hold the rod
and reel, when to wind, when to hold, when to let go. He then moved away
downstream, leaving me to figure out the rest.
Gradually, I felt my right
arm casting into rhythm: hold, release, hold, release. When my line got
caught under a rock in the middle of the river I struggled out against the
current, feeling stubborn, refusing to ask Ray’s help though I knew he was
watching. I fell down twice, had to force my way up.
As we were leaving, Ray
bantered with me about what I was doing out there in the river. “Were you
swimming?”
“Practicing falling.”
We both laughed.
* * *
After lunch on Sunday he
asked, “Do you want to watch while I burn some slash? It’s been pretty dry, but
there’s no wind so I don’t think we have to worry about the fire getting out of
hand.”
Nodding, I followed him
outdoors, avoiding conversation. I was finding Ray to be an odd mixture of
sweet and abrasive, compliant and remote. In spite of my years of figuring
people out, I couldn’t read him, didn’t know what to say, didn’t feel
spontaneous.
Over breakfast that
morning he’d made a point about Love in the Ruins, then was aggravated
because he couldn’t remember the author. I had felt the name begin to form on
my tongue but was equally frustrated.
As we headed up the back
hill, Ray told me he’d always been a walker, walked to his mailbox and back – a
mile each way – in 30 minutes.
Walker, walker. “Walker! His name is Walker something.”
“Walker Percy. Yes!”
It was rejuvenating to
remember together, to begin gaining balance.
Ray started the fire in a low pit next to a huge tree stump that could protect
the fire if the wind came up. I saw a molasses-like chunk on the edge of the
stump and quickly put it to my mouth. It was bitter and sticky.
“That’s red cedar sap. You
thought it was going to be sweet. You’re lucky you got your fingers unstuck.”
We formed a brigade. Ray
brought fallen branches from the back slope of the hill, slippery with pine
needles. I carried the branches from there in bundles, stacking them near the
fire.
After several hours I was
noticeably tired, and he said, “That’s enough.” As perspiration began to cool
on my bare arms, I shivered. Ray suggested I get his long-sleeved shirt hanging
on a nail in the laundry room inside. I found it, walked back out pulling it
on: a soft, deep red and green flannel.
“That looks good on you.
Keep it if you want.”
He gave me the task of
being the fire-watcher, water hose in hand. I sniffed the wind, brushed
drifting ash from my face. He talked about an acquaintance in town who was a
smoke jumper, told a story of seventeen fire fighters who died because they
tried to run from a raging forest fire. His friend saved himself and three
others by building a bunker. They nose-dived into it, waves of fire washing
over them.
As it grew dark, Ray
hissed water on the crisp, hot coals.
We moved to the front
porch. He went to the kitchen and came back with two Black Star beers from a
local brewery. “It’s double-hopped, full-bodied, the finest.”
I’m not a beer lover. But
I wanted to savor what he liked, to get a taste of him. As we sipped, Ray
admitted he was lonely on his mountain. I relaxed in my canvas chair, slid out
my legs, stretched my bare feet. His flannel shirt covered me to the bottom of
my shorts.
“I’d like to see you in
nothing but that shirt.”
Afterward, lying on the
couch inside, I held my legs straight up, waiting for him to bring a towel. He
whistled.
“You have great legs for a
senior citizen.” Then he noticed my silence. “Is it OK if I say that?”
I smiled and turned toward
him. “Yes.”
* * *
Ray grew all his own
vegetables in a large garden surrounded by a steel fence. Watering them was a
cherished daily ritual. He liked his occasional encounters with wild animals on
the rest of the property and didn’t interfere if they came close. I felt a
tender rush when he was affectionately profane toward the deer that ate apples
from the tree in front of his house.
By the third day I’d
fallen into his routines. Every morning he wrote for three hours. Enjoying the
quiet time for myself, I invented yoga postures, meditated, wrote in my
journal, took long walks. In the afternoons, we worked side-by-side in his
flower garden. “Petunias have to be pinched or they’ll become too leggy,” I
told him, “but it hurts me to pinch off life.”
“It’s like separating
Siamese twins, Mary. The ultimate sacrifice.’” By this answer I knew he appreciated
my feelings, didn’t consider them to be – in his words – frou-frou.
That was the day he told
me he’d always wanted to say what Robert Duvall says in Lonesome Dove to
his woman in town: “How ‘bout a little poke, darlin’?” I guessed he’d rehearsed
this, just as I’d rehearsed what I would say when we met. But I liked the line
anyway.
“Oh, darlin’, I’d like
a little poke.” I hugged him, and for the first time his hard body
softened. Perhaps caution held him inflexible until I passed some test whose criteria
were never quite clear. I found, though, even after he seemed more comfortable
with me, after daily pokes, he would never kiss me open-mouthed.
Ray was very particular about how things were done, even washing the outside of
bananas before he peeled them.
When I offered to help him prepare dinner Sunday night he told me to chop the
garlic, then put it in the small yellow ceramic bowl on the counter.
As I started to scrape the
garlic bits into the bowl, he paused from stirring the sauce. “You don’t scrape
from a cutting board with the sharp edge of the knife! You turn the knife and
use the blunt edge.”
“Gee, Ray, it would have
been a lot easier if you’d just sat me down the first morning and given me a
list of all the rules. That way I’d have at least a chance of a passing grade!”
“No, that would take too
long. I’ll teach you as we go.”
Though he was joking, this
interaction fed my growing confusion. I had sat on the leather couch in the den
that morning and wept over one of his poems. But I couldn’t reach deep enough
into the man.
We chatted over dinner – a
pasta of his own invention with anchovies, salad, Pinot Grigio. “The true test
of an interesting woman,” Ray teased, “is if she loves anchovies.” I’d avoided
anchovies my whole life but was damned if I was going to fail this little test.
Suddenly he said, “You’re
lucky, you know. Here you are in this beautiful setting getting the equivalent
of a free workshop with me. There are a lot of women who would pay big bucks
for this.”
“You’re joking.”
“No, I’m serious.”
I was furious. “This isn’t
free. That last-minute plane ticket cost me almost eight hundred dollars. And I
didn’t come here to worship at your feet, Ray. I came to get to know the person
behind the writing.”‘
“They’re one and the same,
Mary.”
I told him he was
arrogant. He said he’d been joking but didn’t like the sour look on my face so
kept up the pretense that he was serious. We didn’t speak for hours, until I
broke the silence.
“Look, I didn’t know you
were joking and I’m sorry I got so angry.”
“It takes a big person to
apologize.”
After breakfast the next
morning, as we watered the vegetables together, he said, “Doesn’t it seem we’ve
known each other forever?” I knew this was as close to an apology as Ray could manage.
* * *
The perfect death. That
had been an unexpected theme. Ray admitted he didn’t want to be buried. “I
can’t stand the thought of being underground, dead or alive.”
Cremation would be good,
we agreed, ashes released on the wind in some memorable place.
“I don’t trust my kids to
follow my wishes, though” I told him. “My son would have me buried. I know he
would. He’d want a grave to visit. Anyway, it’s how to die I want to
know. What do you think is the best way?”
Ray gave me a sober look.
“While dreaming, of course. Just going from one dream to the next.”
We talked about the planet
burning out, the death of animal species, of trees. I was complacent: “I
believe the earth will go on without us. Cockroaches will take over, maybe.”
“The thing I’d hate is
that all my work would be lost, nobody left to read it.”
“Then we’ll just have to
make a time capsule, and hope the cockroaches learn how to read.” I was keeping
it light, but sensed this went deep with Ray – his resolute solitude tempered
by the need to be known.
He’d
cautioned me not to walk into the woods alone, without him and his pistol.
“Cougars wait in trees, could jump on you without warning, snap your neck
instantly.”
I’d thought about this for
days, liked the idea: When I’m ready, I’ll walk into the deep woods away
from the path until a cougar finds me, where there will be no discussion of
cremation or burial, where I’ll go back to the earth.
To Ray I said, “I’ve
changed my mind about planes. I’ll hold out for the cougar death.”
* * *
One morning while he was
locked in his study, I lay on the ground inside the corral, now unused and
overgrown with grass, though Ray had talked about buying a horse. For a long
time I gazed at the sky, framed by aspen, pine, narrow-leaf cottonwood. At
peace, I slowly sat up, admiring the pale, bluish-lavender wildflowers in the
field below.
Two small does appeared,
walking up the hill behind the corral. One of them looked at me, started to dip
her head to feed, stopped, looked again, then pranced off – full of self, head
high, tail stiff. I was charmed.
Eventually, I had the urge
to urinate, went to the far side of the corral, marked my territory, peeing
close to the ground, grazing the wild grass, smelling my own warm, almond
scent. The cougar will know I was here.
* * *
On my last morning at
Ray’s, I strolled barefoot, saw a dandelion growing tall through a prickly
bush. Only the day before it had been a golden globe, but overnight had changed
into the familiar white seed head. I endured pricks from the bush it had
invaded and snapped it low, tried to capture all its tiny parachutes in my free
hand.
Walking toward the back
hill beyond the vegetable garden, I looked down so I wouldn’t stumble and spill
the seeds before I reached the compost pile. Just past the delphiniums at the
border of the flowerbed, I saw a dead field mouse, dark gray guts torn out. Its
front paws were touching, prayer-like, its rear paws flung back as if jumping
were possible.
Ah!
Divining the future from its entrails.
I felt tears rising and
turned my head away from the house, in case Ray had paused in his work and was
looking out the front window.
Tightening my grip on the
dandelion in my left hand, I picked up the small corpse by its tail with thumb
and index finger of my right hand, carried both past the vegetable garden – the
spinach, mustard greens, sweet peas, lettuce, beans.
Giving the mouse a proper send-off, I flung it high into the cooling air over
the back hill, where it landed in a nest of pine needles. There it lay, curled,
among the scrubby bushes, the browning grass, the fallen branches now turning
punky.
The dandelion seeds flew
loose, into the wind.
(Published online in Connotation Press and later in my collection Autobiography Passed through the Sieve of Maya)